Why the Irish Want a Special Immigration Deal

PHOTO: Irish

Ed Pritchard/Getty Images

Immigration from Ireland hit its peak in the 1850s, when more than a million Irish immigrants -- many fleeing their homeland because of famine -- became legal permanent residents.

It's fallen quite a bit since then. In the 2000s, the number of Irish legalizing was only about 1.5 percent of what it was back in its heyday.

Yet Irish interests quietly remain part of the immigration debate in Washington.

An immigration bill being considered in the Senate would give special consideration to several countries for future immigration. South Korea, Poland and Canada are all hoping for their own part of the deal. And so is Ireland.

This wouldn't be the first time the Irish have gotten special consideration.

One of the most notable examples was the so-called diversity lottery. During the early '90s, as the program was getting off the ground, 40 percent of visas were earmarked for Irish, thanks to the late Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.)

But that visa allotment was temporary, and groups like the Irish Lobby for Immigration Reform (ILIR) are hopeful the Senate bill will create a more permanent program. A provision added by Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) would make 10,500 renewable visas available to Irish nationals each year.

To see why the Irish might need their own deal, I spoke to Niall O'Dowd, the founder of the ILIR and the editor of the New York-based Irish Voice.

Adverse effects of the 1965 immigration law

Prior to 1965, the immigration system overtly favored European nationals over people coming from other parts of the world. Then Congress passed an immigration bill that scrapped that system in favor of more even visa distribution.

While that meant opportunities for immigrants from Latin America and Asia -- and ended clear discrimination -- it cut visas for European nationals.

"It's been impossible for Irish people to emigrate legally to America since 1965," O'Dowd said. "The new preferences militated against Irish people; indeed, any people coming from Europe."

He's right. While the migration flows from Ireland are much smaller than from a place like Mexico, for example, you can see a drop in Irish that were able to become legal permanent residents around the time that the 1965 law was passed.

That said, part of the reason the number of visas to Irish dropped was that they were no longer benefiting from a discriminatory system.

Irish Still Come, Just Illegally

Niall O'Dowd estimates that there are 50,000 undocumented Irish living in places like New York, Boston and Chicago.

Out of 11 million undocumented immigrants, that isn't a huge number. But O'Dowd believes that the poor economy in Ireland and the historic migratory ties to the U.S. will keep Irish people coming.

"Our people are still coming here, but they're coming illegally, which is no way to go," he said. "We're trying to regularize future flow."

Creating legal pathways for immigrants who would be coming anyway makes sense. But the countries that send the most people illegally aren't getting this type of deal.

Which makes you wonder, why Ireland...

A Shared History -- and Connections

"We've always had a program to help Irish immigration," Sen. Schumer said at an immigration reform hearing on Thursday. "America and Ireland are bound together by history, traditions and common ancestry."

While that's true, a lot of nations share history and heritage with the U.S.: Germany, Italy, Mexico, the Philippines. But we don't typically use that as a basis to give out visas.

O'Dowd explained how Ireland found its way onto the immigration reform agenda:

"We have strong political clout," he told me. "We're very friendly with Chuck Schumer here in New York, he's been a great supporter on this issue...We're working with John McCain who's been a friend of ours for years, as well."

In the end, that's probably the best answer.

The boom in Irish migration to the U.S. happened 150 years ago, but the long-term impact of that wave still resonates. More than 34 million Americans claim Irish ancestry, according to the Census Bureau.

Listening to the immigration debate in the Senate, discussing visas for the Irish is a rare moment when the conversation shifts from questions of the economy and "rule of law" to sentimentality.

Obviously there are Irish immigrants who have a desire to come to the U.S. legally. But it's hard to make a special case just based on desire when there are so many other people who want to come here from around the world.

NOT SURE HOW TO GET FUSION ON YOUR TV? CLICK HERE TO FIND OUT!
Alt

Immigration Reform is a heated political issue that we view from all angles in the hope of getting politicians to address those impacted by the decisions they make.

comments powered by Disqus

Immigration Reform

Immigration Reform Backers Draft GOP Hit List

Activists will keep the pressure on the Republicans who represent districts with a concentration of voters who might care about immigration reform, according to Dawn Le, the deputy campaign manager for the Alliance for Citizenship, a pro-reform coalition that includes labor unions and liberal activist organizations.