uphill battle

After Katrina, where did all the New Orleans black teachers go?

via FirstLine

NEW ORLEANS —Educator Kristi Walton was born, bred, and trained as a teacher in her hometown of New Orléans. She attended the city’s Audubon Montessori School and Benjamin Franklin High School, where she took an introduction to teaching class at the age of 17. She also learned from her mother, who spent more than 30 years teaching at New Orléans’ John McDonogh High School. Walton earned a master’s degree in early education at the University of New Orleans, and has taught kindergarten at Langston Hughes Academy since 2008.

In New Orléans, a city that relied heavily on young teachers from out of town to staff its schools after Hurricane Katrina, Walton’s career path has become increasingly rare. That’s partly because several of the local training programs that provided a pathway into teaching for Walton and countless others no longer exist.

A Hechinger Report analysis of federal data shows that the number of education degrees handed out by New Orleans’ universities plummeted in the years after Hurricane Katrina. In 2003, New Orleans’ seven universities handed out 265 bachelor’s degrees in education, according to federal data. Last year, they gave out just 93. Some education departments were shuttered in the weeks and months after Katrina hit in 2005, as universities restructured to avoid financial ruin, while others have struggled over the last decade due to abysmal state support for higher education and a preference among charter school leaders for teachers from alternative training programs like Teach for America.

Indeed, in the years after Katrina, a lack of supply and demand for locally trained teachers, and the loss of local training programs, contributed to a dramatic racial shift in the teacher workforce. During the 2003-04 school year, black teachers accounted for 72% of New Orleans’ educators. By 2014, they made up only 49%. And the proportion of teachers who attended college in the city, a rough measure of the number of teachers with local roots, also declined precipitously, falling from 60% in 2005 to 34% in 2014.

Walton thinks her local roots have improved her teaching.

“This is a very culture-heavy city, and the more teachers you have who know that culture, the better the schools will be,” she said. “Administrators and charter school networks are just starting to see how important that is.”

In fact, research shows several benefits to hiring teachers who reflect the racial and cultural diversity of their students, including better student outcomes. That’s part of the reason, in New Orléans, black and local teachers have become a more sought-after bunch in recent years.

But the supply of locally trained teachers has dried up, after Louisiana officials slashed state higher-education spending by nearly 40% since 2008, with more cuts on the horizon. According to the nonpartisan Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, only Arizona and Illinois have cut higher-education spending per student more.

Fiscal issues have devastated the city’s largest education school at the University of New Orléans (UNO). In 2015, UNO granted 48 bachelor’s degrees in education, down from 136 in 2003. The university also made steep cuts to its master’s degree offerings. In 2014, UNO eliminated special-education and early-education teacher training programs to try to balance its budget. And, in July, the university merged its standalone education school into its liberal arts college.

Private schools have also been affected. Loyola University New Orléans shuttered its education department in 2006, although it still offers a program for aspiring music teachers. Dillard University, a historically black college, stopped offering education degrees in 2010, saying that it would instead work with the state-run Recovery School District to offer an alternative route into teaching for its students. But that initiative never got off the ground.

Over much of the same time period, local universities also saw a steep decline in demand for their education graduates. In the months after Katrina, all 4,600 of New Orléans’ public school teachers were fired. Louisiana took over the majority of the city’s schools, and eventually converted all of them into publicly funded, privately run charter schools. Some of these schools hired back only a few of the fired educators, choosing instead to rely heavily on uncertified teachers and candidates from alternative programs like Teach For America (TFA) and The New Teacher Project, which run nationally. Most were white and new to the profession.

The percentage of New Orléans educators with teaching certifications dropped from 79% in 2004 to 56% in 2013, according to a report by Education Research Alliance New Orléans. And between 2005 and 2014, the number of New Orléans public school teachers who had attended college in the city declined by more than 40%.

Renee Akbar, chair of the education division at Xavier University, said enrollment has been down since Katrina, partly because of charter schools’ strong embrace of alternative preparation programs like TFA.

“In the first few years with the [charter-management organizations] partnering with groups like TFA and TeachNOLA … there was a clear preference and our folks weren’t getting those jobs, and that impacted our enrollment numbers,” said Akbar, who has been at Xavier since 2003. “Some of this is national. Fewer students want to become teachers in general, but everything that happened [in New Orléans] didn’t help.”

“The loss of local training programs contributed to a dramatic racial shift in the teacher workforce.”

Brian Beabout, associate professor of education at UNO, said he thinks there was a bias after Katrina against teachers from traditional training programs. But that bias has subsided more recently, he added.

“Initially, charter leaders were looking for ‘mission alignment’: Were you on board to do whatever it took to get kids to pass tests, and go to college, even if it meant staying until 8 PM?” he said. “But now, a lot of those charter leaders … are talking more about sustainability.”

And to increase “sustainability,” it’s necessary to hire more local teachers with roots and connections to the city, Beabout argued.

There’s a very practical reason to hire teachers with local roots: They’re far more likely to stay around—and this isn’t just a New Orléans phenomenon. One recent study found that teachers who studied education in college are far more likely to stay in the profession. What’s more, New Orleans’ teacher turnover has been up a lot since Katrina.

Across America, many urban school districts are recognizing that they need to hire teacher workforces that better reflect the diversity of their students. The academic benefits to students of having a same-race teacher have been well-documented. Beyond serving as role models, these teachers are better able to make lessons culturally relevant, and often have an easier time building relationships with students and parents. In New Orléans, 89% of public school students are black, and many of the new white teacher have struggled to connect with students.

As Akbar concluded, “We are now at this point where we have fewer teacher candidates [than] the city needs.”

In the last few years, some New Orléans policymakers and school leaders have begun looking for ways to partner with local teacher training programs, partly to regrow the number of black teachers.

The Louisiana education department has used Believe and Prepare grants (state money intended to spur partnerships between schools and teacher-preparation programs) to entice New Orléans charters to collaborate more with local universities.

Xavier University has used these grants, and other funding, to create a new program where current Xavier students spend yearlong residencies teaching along mentor teachers at local charter networks. The hope is that the Xavier students will be able to work full-time in those same schools after they graduate. Participating charter networks include KIPP, New Orléans College Prep and FirstLine Schools.

According to Xavier’s Akbar, around half of her students are from the New Orléans area. Currently, the majority are finding teaching jobs in the suburbs of New Orléans after graduating, a trend she said started after Katrina—and one that she hopes will change with the residency program, which is still in its planning stages.

“I dream of a point in time when we become a city that really teaches its own.”

- Ben Kleban, founder and president of New Orleans College Prep

Ben Kleban, founder and president of New Orléans College Prep, a network of four charter schools, admits that was late in recognizing the importance of recruiting local talen from local universities.

“I dream of a point in time when we become a city that really teaches its own,” said Kleban. “If we are going to reach that goal of having a much greater proportion of our teaching workforce coming from our public school graduates … local universities are absolutely the way to do that.”

His network hopes to take in a large number of Xavier residents next school year.

Another charter network, ReNEW Schools, used a Believe and Prepare grant to start a similar residency program with Tulane University, in which students spend a year teaching alongside a mentor educator. Amber Morgan, director of quality review and professional learning at ReNEW, said they decided to work with Tulane because the university already had residency programs in other city schools. But there are limitations: None of the Tulane residents are from New Orléans, so it’s not a good vehicle for increasing the number of homegrown teachers. Morgan said she hopes to expand to work with other universities, like Xavier, which enroll more students who grew up in the city.

There’s also the Honoré Center for Undergraduate Achievement at Southern University at New Orléans, a public historically black university. That program is giving financial and academic support to black men who graduated from local high schools. While at SUNO, they must either major in education or complete 12 hours of education courses, and then enroll in an alternate teaching certification program after graduation. In return, they promise to teach in New Orléans for at least two years after completing their degree. The program, which is in its fifth year, only accepts a handful of students each year.

The trickle of education graduates from local universities presents a huge hurdle to rebuilding a more local teaching force, according to Luis Mirón, who directs the Institute for Quality and Equity in Education at Loyola University New Orléans.

“It’s going to be a long road,” he said. “With the schools of education unlikely to come back, the structural challenges are just enormous.”

Mirón added that these new initiatives, particularly the Xavier University residences, offer promising but limited solutions to the problem. “The prognosis for bringing some balance to the teaching force over the next few years will depend on how well all of these nonprofits and school leaders work together,” he said.

Andre Perry, a frequent columnist for The Hechinger Report and former associate dean at the University of New Orleans’ education school, is more optimistic about the future of university programs, particularly since Bobby Jindal is no longer Louisiana’s governor. Jindal initiated many of the steep cuts to higher-education institutions.

“Now that we are out of the Jindal era, there’s hope,” Perry said. “It’s easy to tear schools apart; it’s harder to put them back together again. Developing programs is a decades-long strategy, but at least we can start the process of building these programs back up again.”

UNO professor Beabout said New Orléans’ education schools can rebuild, but that the new teacher programs will only win out over alternative certification programs like TeachNOLA on quality.

“It’s about having the best student teaching internships around, and it’s about offering specialized programs, in areas like teaching students with disabilities and English language learners, things that schools in New Orléans are dying for,” he said. “The future of the standard bachelor’s programs [in education] will hinge on how well schools do those things.”

“The trickle of education graduates from local universities presents a huge hurdle to rebuilding a more local teaching force.”

Many see these programs as key to rebuilding a more stable teacher pipeline, and providing New Orleans’ students and parents with the kind of consistency found elsewhere.

“I still could actually go back to my high school in Atlanta, and see some of the same faces that I had as a student many years ago,” said Maggie Runyan-Shefa, co-CEO of New Schools for New Orléans, which is helping fund Xavier’s residency program. “That consistency is really important for families and kids. That’s why we are focused on funding pathways that attract people with local roots, and by that I mean someone who either grew up here or attended college, here, and really wants to make New Orléans home—someone who has a vested interest in the community.”

Walton, the kindergarten teacher at Langston Hughes, said she’s found a school that is building those kinds of relationships with families.

“When I came home after Katrina, I was looking for a home base,” said Walton, who spent three years in Atlanta after the storm, and is now an award-winning veteran teacher. “My mom taught at John McDonogh for almost 30 years in the same classroom; she grew roots. I think I’ve found that, here. I’ve watched my first kindergartners grow into eighth-graders.”

This story was produced by The Hechinger Report, a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. Read more about teacher preparation.